Skip to content
scopal affairs, foyer

The Ones Who Move Through You

A part of me wants to act; another wants to stop. On parts, inner voices and changing the way we relate to them.

Posted on

The Ones Who Move Through You
The Ones Who Move Through You

On the multiplicity of the mind, self-critical inner speech, and the image of an orchestra


I. The Mind Is Not Singular

The image of one voice, one will and one stable self is familiar. Everyday language also gives us another image: “part of me wants this; part of me does not”. A conflict can be experienced as a conversation in which no single speaker has the whole account. That experience is the starting point here.

I find the image of a single, stable inner speaker too narrow for the experiences considered here. Parts work offers one way to describe competing impulses without treating every difference as a defect. That is the perspective I choose for this essay, not a finding shared by every psychological tradition.

Freud’s id, ego and superego describe agencies with different demands. Jung’s concepts of Shadow, Persona, Anima and Animus, and Self offer another account of psychic organization. His theory treats archetypal patterns as more than products of individual biography. These are theoretical proposals with different histories; their vocabulary of plurality is a point of contact, not evidence that they describe one shared inner cast.

Richard Schwartz developed Internal Family Systems (IFS) from his work as a family therapist. The model carries a systemic question into accounts of inner experience: how do different parts relate, polarize and attempt to protect one another? What was a relationship among family members becomes a vocabulary for relationships within a person.

IFS assumes a multiplicity of parts with distinct perspectives and intentions. Within the model, parts are natural, carry valuable qualities and can be pushed into extreme roles by burdens. A critic, a caretaker or a protector can then become dominant or rigid. This gives IFS its language for inner conflict; it does not make every feeling or symptom evidence of a discrete subpersonality.

Gunther Schmidt approaches inner experience through systemic therapy and Ericksonian hypnotherapy. His experiential networks (Erlebnisnetzwerke) describe patterns activated through context, attention and relationships. Utilization asks whether an unwanted pattern could become useful in another context, or through a different relationship to it. I am interested in that change of question: from removing an experience to examining how it is organized.

Jung’s archetypes, Schwartz’s parts and Schmidt’s experiential networks are different models. I bring them together around a practical interest in relating to inner conflict. That shared interest does not make their accounts of the psyche interchangeable.


II. The Architecture of Parts

Protectors, Exiles, and the Logic of the Inner System

In Schwartz's IFS model, parts fall into three broad categories – not as fixed types but as functional roles that any part can be forced into.

IFS calls vulnerable parts carrying painful experience exiles. In the model, the internal system keeps their pain out of awareness to avoid being overwhelmed. This image describes a relationship between vulnerability and protection; it is not a literal map of memories stored somewhere inside the mind.

Managers are the proactive protectors in IFS. Planning, controlling, pleasing others or demanding perfection can be read as attempts to prevent painful feelings from surfacing. The model asks what a particular strategy is trying to prevent and what it costs the person. The same outward behaviour need not have the same function for everyone.

Firefighters are the model’s reactive protectors, mobilized when painful feelings break through. IFS may interpret behaviours such as substance use, binge eating or self-harm as attempts at emergency relief. This is a possible functional reading within the model, rather than a diagnosis of the cause or a claim that the behaviour reliably provides relief.

IFS assumes a positive intention even where a part’s strategy is destructive. I take this as a question to try: what might the strategy be attempting to protect? The answer has to be explored with the person, rather than supplied in advance by the category.

The Self Behind the Parts

Underneath and behind all parts, Schwartz posits the existence of the Self – not as another part, but as a qualitatively different kind of presence. The Self is characterized by what Schwartz calls the "eight C's": curiosity, calm, clarity, compassion, confidence, creativity, courage, and connectedness. It is not constructed by therapy. It is revealed when parts step back – when they "unblend" from the person's awareness enough that the Self can lead.

IFS describes the Self as undamaged by trauma, while parts carry burdens. This is a consequential assumption of the model, and it sits in tension with the plurality that interests me. I find the image useful as an orientation towards curiosity and care; I do not take it as proof of an unchanging inner substance.

Jung’s Self belongs to his account of individuation and psychic wholeness. Comparing it with the IFS Self can reveal similarities in vocabulary, but does not show that the two concepts identify the same center. Their different theoretical commitments remain part of the comparison.


III. Archetypes as Recurring Patterns

I read Jung’s archetypes less as a fixed cast than as patterns around which experience can gather. The gravitational field is an image I find useful: something can draw attention without dictating every movement. In Jung’s account, the Shadow concerns what conscious identity does not acknowledge. It invites a question about what an image of myself leaves out, rather than a law assigning a hidden opposite to every trait.

The Trickster offers me an image of disruption: humour, ambiguity and paradox entering an arrangement that has become rigid. The disruption can make another response imaginable, but it can also become evasion or manipulation. The name does not decide which is happening in a particular encounter.

I use the Seer as a further image: a hunch appears before I can explain how I reached it. It may direct attention towards something overlooked. If I treat the hunch as certainty, the same image can conceal the need to check it. This describes a tension in how I use intuition, not a clinical category.

The Deep Mother, in the vocabulary I am using here, names a form of care that can remain present without immediately fixing something. I use the image without assigning it to a gender. It also raises a question about boundaries: when does staying close become taking over?

These names do not constitute a complete taxonomy. Jung’s account of archetypes gives recurrent patterns a basis beyond individual biography; the examples above are my readings of some such images. Recognizing a resemblance across stories or people does not by itself establish an inherited psychic structure.

IFS makes a different proposal: parts have non-extreme roles and can be helped to release burdens. I draw a limited comparison with the preceding images: criticism might become discernment, control might become organization, impulsiveness might leave room for spontaneity. These are possible changes to explore, not a reconstruction of everyone’s original nature or an equation of parts with archetypes.


IV. The Problem of Volume: When a Part Gets Too Loud

For the experiences considered here, volume is a useful image. A critical thought can become so prominent that other responses are hard to hear. An anxious plan can turn every imagined future into a catastrophe. The orchestra has not disappeared, but one instrument seems to occupy the whole room.

This is what Schmidt calls a Problemtrance – a problem trance. It is a state in which one particular experiential network has captured the person's attention so completely that it feels like the whole of reality. The person is not thinking about the inner critic's message; they are inside it, merged with it, unable to see it as one perspective among many. The trance is maintained by the narrowing of attention – a tunnel vision in which only the data that confirms the part's worldview is perceived, and everything else is filtered out.

Schmidt draws on hypnosis to describe how attention can become absorbed in a problem pattern. His approach explores deliberate changes of attention, posture, imagery and context as possible ways to make other experiences accessible. This offers a route to try alongside examining a thought’s content; it does not make argument or analysis futile.


V. Pattern Interruption: The Art of Changing the Signal

What can be changed when an inner sentence keeps returning in the same way? I focus first on its form: the tone, rhythm, posture and setting in which it is experienced. A change there offers one possible experiment, before or alongside an argument about whether the sentence is true.

Utilization: Schmidt's Core Principle

Utilization, following Erickson, asks how what a person brings can become a resource in the work. Schmidt applies this question to unwanted experiences as well as wanted ones. A pattern might be useful in a different context, at a different intensity or in relation to another goal. Its present cost still matters.

Take the self-critical sentence “You are not good enough”. One response is to examine its claims and look for counterevidence. Another question concerns its delivery: does it arrive as a whisper, a shout, a familiar person’s tone? The same words may be experienced differently depending on that setting.

In his writing on “basic truths”, Schmidt proposes making habitual beliefs explicit and varying how they are enacted: for instance as a little election speech or a ritualized movement. The broader experiment I take from this is to vary the delivery of a self-critical sentence: say it slowly, give it a different rhythm, or sing it.

The words remain “You are not good enough”. A different rhythm might make their delivery noticeable where it previously felt inseparable from their truth. It might also feel awkward or change nothing. What interests me is whether a difference in form makes another relationship to the sentence available.

This is how I use the idea of pattern interruption here: introduce a difference and notice the response. The observation matters more than completing the trick. If the experiment does not help, its failure is information about this attempt, not evidence that the person has resisted change.

Unblending: Schwartz's Approach

IFS uses unblending for a shift in which a person can notice a part’s perspective without being wholly absorbed in it. Its vocabulary emphasizes a relationship to the part. That differs from changing the delivery of a sentence, even where both approaches invite some distance from an immediate experience.

“A part of me feels not good enough” is one way to try this shift. It places the feeling beside other possible perspectives rather than making it the whole account of who I am. In IFS, curiosity towards the part is associated with Self-leadership. Saying the sentence does not by itself establish that a person has reached that state.

Within this approach, a critic might be explored as a protector afraid of rejection or failure. That is a question, not a history to invent for the person. The exploration could reveal another concern, or the protector image might not fit. Listening includes letting the account change.

The Orchestrator Position

Schmidt’s steering position and Schwartz’s Self-leadership both interest me as ways of describing a change in relation to inner experience. I place them beside one another without equating a context-dependent observing position with the Self posited by IFS.

This position is not detachment. It is not the cold observation of an inner life held at arm's length. It is engaged presence – the capacity to feel what a part feels without becoming identical to it. A conductor feels the music. But the conductor is not the trumpet, is not the drum, is not the violin. The conductor holds the space in which all instruments can play, adjusts the balance, brings forward what is needed, and quiets what is too loud – not by removing it from the orchestra, but by changing its relationship to the whole.


VI. The Quiet Work: Reframing Without Losing the Signal

The wish for silence is understandable when a critical sentence is exhausting. The question I take from these models is whether something in the experience can be heard differently: an expectation, a fear, a demand that has become too loud. That question leaves room both for the wish for relief and for attention to what the sentence is doing.

The image I return to is orchestration.

A critic might point towards a standard I care about, or repeat a demand I no longer accept. An anxious plan might contain useful preparation alongside an exaggerated threat. I want to distinguish what deserves attention from the manner in which it insists on being heard. No particular history follows automatically from the voice’s tone.

The orientation I draw from these readings is to ask how a relationship to an inner pattern might change. This is my practical synthesis; Jungian work, IFS and hypnosystemic approaches do not thereby become one method or promise the same result.

The critic doesn't need to shout. It can advise. The planner doesn't need to catastrophize. It can prepare. The impulse doesn't need to override. It can request. The shift is not in what the part knows but in how it communicates – and in whether someone is listening.

Schmidt’s changes of form direct attention towards how an experience is organized. Schwartz’s unblending directs attention towards a relationship with a part. I keep both questions available without requiring their answers to coincide.


VII. Reading Across Traditions

IFS is a clinical model with particular assumptions about parts and Self. When I read it alongside contemplative traditions, I am making a comparison across different histories and purposes. Those traditions are not earlier versions of IFS, and their presence does not independently validate its assumptions.

The koshas and Atman belong to philosophical and contemplative contexts that differ from IFS. Images of layers and a self may invite comparison, but Atman is not a clinical category and the koshas are not IFS parts. I use the comparison to examine my own assumptions about an inner center, not to declare the concepts equivalent.

A comparison becomes useful to me where it makes a difference visible: what does a particular account mean by self, suffering or liberation? The answer changes what a similar-looking practice is for. Reading across these vocabularies asks me to attend to that change rather than gather them as confirmations of one inner architecture.


VIII. Working With Your Parts: A Practical Orientation

The following are five invitations to experiment with self-critical inner speech in everyday conflicts. They are prompts for observation, not a treatment protocol or an explanation of symptoms. The question throughout is whether a particular way of noticing or speaking makes room for another response.

1. Try Naming a Part

Try putting “a part of me” before a self-critical sentence: “A part of me thinks I will fail”. Notice whether that wording creates room for another perspective. It may help to hear the thought as one voice among others; it may also feel artificial. You do not have to adopt the model for the observation to matter.

2. Ask About the Concern

If arguing with the sentence brings you back to the same point, try a different question: what concern might be expressed here? What am I afraid could happen? What would I need in this situation? A question may open another view of the conflict. It need not uncover a protective intention, and examining the sentence’s truth remains an option.

3. Experiment With the Delivery

Choose a familiar self-critical phrase and vary one element of its delivery: speed, rhythm, volume, or the voice you imagine saying it. Read it slowly from the page, or try singing it. Notice whether its effect changes. A variation can make the form audible; it does not guarantee that a thought loop stops or that distress is relieved.

4. Consider a Possible Protective Function

When you put off an everyday task, ask whether postponing it might be protecting you from something, such as the prospect of a disappointing result. Other explanations may fit better: tiredness, unclear instructions or competing demands. The protector image is one possible perspective to examine, rather than a cause to assign to a behaviour or symptom.

5. Try the Steering Position

Imagine hearing the different concerns as instruments in a room. Which is loudest? Which is hard to hear? What small next action could take more than one concern into account? I use “steering position” for this attempted coordination. The conductor is an image for an activity, not evidence of a permanent observer behind experience.


IX. The Ones Who Move Through You

The title names the image I want to keep: voices and patterns can arrive without feeling chosen, yet do not have to supply the whole account of a person. Parts, archetypes and experiential networks give different descriptions of that experience. I let the image connect my questions without making those descriptions identical.

In the Jungian vocabulary, I can ask what a self-image has put in shadow. In IFS, I can ask what a critical part fears. With Schmidt, I can ask how the same words might be experienced in another form or context. Each question directs attention differently. None supplies the person’s history before they have spoken.

Listening, in this sense, means noticing a signal without letting its volume decide its truth. I can consider the demand, question its authority and look for another response. The orchestra image helps me imagine coordination without having to silence every instrument first.

Everyday reflection has limits. Severe or persistent distress, trauma-related experiences and self-harm need individual professional assessment and support; the exercises above are not a substitute. A helpful setting and pace cannot be read from a metaphor.

I take the shift from “I am my loudest part” to “I can try to hear that part” as an invitation. Whether it opens room for a different response is something to notice in practice, not a result the image can promise.

The ones who move through you: a phrase for the plurality I want to hear without turning it into a fixed identity. I return to the orchestra, and to the possibility that listening could change the arrangement.


References

Freud, S. (1923). Das Ich und das Es. Leipzig: Internationaler Psychoanalytischer Verlag. [English: The Ego and the Id, trans. J. Riviere, 1927.]

Jung, C. G. (1934/1954). The Archetypes and the Collective Unconscious. Collected Works, Vol. 9, Part 1. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Schmidt, G. (2004). Einführung in die hypnosystemische Therapie und Beratung. Heidelberg: Carl-Auer-Systeme-Verlag.

Schmidt, G. (2000). Die Utilisation von „Wahr-Gebungs-Prozessen" aus der „inneren" und „äußeren Welt" von TherapeutInnen/BeraterInnen. Familiendynamik, 2/2000.

Schmidt, G. (2015). Liebesaffären zwischen Problem und Lösung: Hypnosystemisches Arbeiten in schwierigen Kontexten. 6th ed. Heidelberg: Carl-Auer-Systeme-Verlag.

Schwartz, R. C. (1995). Internal Family Systems Therapy. New York: Guilford Press.

Schwartz, R. C. (2021). No Bad Parts: Healing Trauma and Restoring Wholeness with the Internal Family Systems Model. Boulder: Sounds True.

Schwartz, R. C. (2023). Introduction to Internal Family Systems. Boulder: Sounds True.

Erickson, M. H., & Rossi, E. L. (1979). Hypnotherapy: An Exploratory Casebook. New York: Irvington.

Image viewer